beffroi-tools/docs/rundown-corpus.md

147 lines
9.6 KiB
Markdown

# Rundown evaluation corpus
The first implementation was evaluated on two supplied XLSX workbooks (three
sheets), two supplied PDFs, and five downloaded public XLSX workbooks. Source
originals remain in ignored `rundowns/` and `downloads/rundown-corpus/`; they are
not redistributed in Git. Automated regression tests use synthetic data.
The [public source manifest](../crates/rundown-converter/tests/public-corpus.json)
records download URLs, source pages, SHA-256 hashes and retrieval date. Downloads
are manual research inputs, never a network dependency of CI. Templates are not
a representative accuracy benchmark; these observations establish specific
behaviors and limitations, not a general success percentage.
## Supplied examples
| Example | Evidence and result |
| --- | --- |
| ESTIVALES, OUVERTURE | Correctly identifies Heure, Durée and Contenu / Détail. Shared merged durations remain one timer; merged windows with individual durations become consecutive cues with leftover slack. Untimed production directions need a note classification. Final 11:45 cue lacks duration and blocks export pending clarification. |
| ESTIVALES, CLOTURE | Five timing blocks. With the explicit `untimed_as_notes` policy, converts to five timers; all original continuation/direction rows remain in the IR and exported notes. This policy is a test scenario, not a confirmed interpretation from the owner. |
| Plénière 2, Feuil1 | Both C and D are named TIMER and contain plausible durations. Returns `AMBIGUOUS_COLUMN`; parent-segment versus child-cue timing needs clarification. No automatic conversion is claimed. |
| Montage PDF | Text is extractable, but includes overlapping logistics tasks, missing durations and different locations. Not a single established timer sequence. |
| Exploitation/démontage PDF | Text is extractable; page-spanning directions, simultaneous activities and untimed arrivals require track and row classification. PDF import remains a stretch goal. |
Private originals contain production details and contacts. Tests and documentation
do not reproduce those details. An unchanged local file can be inspected with
`rundown-converter inspect INPUT --json`; this output contains the original cells,
so treat it like the source document.
## PDF feasibility trial
A bounded follow-up trial attempted automatic table recovery from all 17 pages
of the two supplied PDFs. Result: useful text/table recovery, but no dependable
whole-document timer conversion. PDF importer work is paused; the application
continues to return `PDF_REQUIRES_REVIEW`. This is a finding about these samples,
not evidence that all PDF rundowns are unsuitable.
### Extraction attempts
First compare `pdftotext -layout` with word coordinates from
`pdftotext -bbox-layout`. Plain reading order sometimes joins a clock and its
activity, while multiline cells and vertically centred text prevent reliable
row detection from baselines alone. The rendered first page of each document
was inspected to compare the recovered coordinates with the visible grid.
Then use `pdftocairo -svg` to recover the table borders. In these files the borders
are thin filled rectangles. A temporary Python standard-library prototype
clusters their coordinates into column boundaries and row bands, assigns words
by their bounding-box centres, and records missing horizontal borders as possible
vertical cell spans. This is specific to ruled, text-based PDFs; it does not
establish support for scans, borderless tables or other PDF drawing conventions.
The first geometry pass lost a column on two Montage continuation pages where
the left border was absent. It also missed text above the first visible border
on some pages. A second pass aligns column boundaries across the document and
extends the outer row bounds to include body text. It recovers four columns for
Montage and five for Exploitation on every page.
| Measurement | Montage | Exploitation/démontage |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Pages | 4 | 13 |
| Nonempty geometric row bands | 33 | 123 |
| Body words assigned to cells | 714 | 2,645 |
| Repeated page-heading words excluded | 16 | 39 |
| Populated time cells | 13 | 46 |
| Explicit start/end ranges | 1 | 15 |
| Start-only cells | 9 | 31 |
| Other time-cell values | `TBC`, `01H/2H`, `2H MAX` | None |
All non-heading words were assigned in this second pass. That is extraction
coverage, **not** proof that every cell boundary, inherited start or event grouping
is correct. Row bands are geometric subdivisions, not a count of semantic events.
Missing grid borders and cross-page continuations still need interpretation.
### Timing experiment and stop decision
For a deliberately generous trial, write the recovered rows to temporary CSVs
with guessed Start/Title/Owner/Location/Notes headers and enable the existing
`untimed_as_notes` policy. No start or duration is filled from the next row.
Keep page/bounding-box and possible-merge evidence in separate temporary JSON;
this CSV trial does not resolve or automatically apply those ambiguous spans.
Montage stops at column validation on its three unresolved time-cell values.
Exploitation reaches IR construction but reports 31 missing durations. Its 12
orphan-note diagnostics are downstream consequences of unresolved preceding
events, not 12 additional extraction failures. A shared time cell can cover
several simultaneous tasks; treating them as consecutive cues is unjustified.
As a diagnostic only, test the explicit-range subset separately. Montage's single
range validates, but that excludes almost the entire document. Exploitation's
15 ranges yield 14 candidate timers and one untimed break, with six overlapping
predecessor pairs and three gap-overlap diagnostics. This subset also omits the
31 start-only entries, so it is not an acceptable converted rundown even if
those conflicts were removed. **No partial Ontime project was published.**
The remaining obstacles are semantic: selecting simultaneous tracks, deciding
whether untimed rows are instructions or events, distinguishing arrivals and
cutoff markers from timers, and interpreting uncertain overnight deadlines.
Neither a following start nor a missing table border supplies that information.
Per the requested stop condition, no experimental reader or new runtime dependency
was added. Revisit with a sequential PDF containing explicit durations/end times,
or after adding explicit track and row-role selection to the neutral model.
Temporary extractions and the prototype stay outside Git; no private PDF content
or contact details are redistributed.
## Public examples
| Source | Result and useful variation |
| --- | --- |
| [Stagetimer](https://stagetimer.io/blog/what-is-a-run-of-show/) | Header below title blocks, Excel serial times, formula placeholders. The populated row has inconsistent start/end/duration values; validation returns `CONFLICTING_TIMES`. |
| [Attenditai](https://attenditai.com/templates/run-of-show-template) | Instruction sheet plus blank formula-driven schedule. Formula cells without usable cached values require recalculation/population; no invented events. |
| [Joinways](https://joinways.app/solutions/run-of-show-example) | AM/PM times, section labels embedded in the clock column, parallel setup tasks. Unmerged labels require explicit row classifications before column inference can succeed; overlaps then require separate tracks. |
| [LiveFocus](https://livefocus.net/guides/event-run-of-show-template) | Three sheets, cached formula durations in minutes and fractional-day clocks. Minute units are inferred from start/end pairs. Blank formula rows and full-width merged footer are structural. The completed example reports overlapping activities. |
| [Novus](https://examples.novusstreamsolutions.com/templates/planning/event-run-of-show-csv) | String clock times and two-part durations. Whole-column comparison with start/end pairs establishes `hh:mm`; the populated XLSX sheet converts without a profile. |
Two additional institutional sources (Moira Shire and Monash University) rejected
requests with HTTP 403. A speaker toolkit page exposed no direct workbook link.
No authentication or access restrictions were bypassed.
## Ontime verification
Generated native JSON was run through Ontime's actual rundown parser and metadata
calculation from version 4.15.1, source commit
[`0fe52483eb756228589321b83c3b0f810dfb36b1`](https://github.com/cpvalente/ontime/commit/0fe52483eb756228589321b83c3b0f810dfb36b1).
The synthetic lunch example preserves all four events, their start/end/duration
values and unlinked starts; Ontime calculates a 5,400,000 ms gap before resumption.
The five-event closing-sheet scenario and eleven-event public Novus example
also preserve every timer through that parser. This verifies parser and schedule
semantics, not an operated live show or every
Ontime project section. The user's installed version still needs confirmation.
## Regression coverage
Synthetic tests cover whole-column contradictions, duplicate TIMER headers,
ambiguous duration units resolved by other rows, Excel time values and merges,
notes/markers, gaps, conflicting triples, backward times, negative durations,
output collisions, source preservation, cancellation, CLI exit codes and desktop
worker state. Neither private originals nor public binaries are CI fixtures.
## Validation of the first implementation
All workspace Rust tests and 43 Python tests passed, along with formatting,
Clippy and warning-free Rustdoc. Whole-workspace line coverage is 86.20% against
the 75% gate, including production GUI/PDF code. The native converter Setup window
was visually inspected; headless egui tests exercise Review/Results, compact
layouts, worker completion, errors and export. Full interactive operation on
Windows/macOS and a live Ontime playback session have not been verified.